Hello Guest
  • Sign up for free and join our community.
Dynamic Range - CD vs Vinyl?
1 Replies
4932 Views
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
November 16, 2013, 06:07:29 AM
    • VinylAudio.net
  • BSD2000
  • Administrator
  • Trade Count: (2)
  • Posts: 623 Male
    Offline
    Pennsylvania Send PM
    • Share Post
I came across this video today discussing and comparing the dynamic range of a song from a CD and vinyl release of the same album:

Why the TT Meter doesn't work on vinyl

After watching the video, a few things stood out to me and I find myself disagreeing with premise of his argument - that the dynamic range measurements of vinyl cannot be trusted when comparing the same song to a CD rip.

First, he states that he engineered and mastered the recording digitally and 'peak limited' the audio to flatten out the peaks; and that he used that digital master to cut the vinyl. That's a huge mistake. Vinyl cut from an overly processed digital master really defeats the advantages and character of the vinyl format. Sadly, this method is the most widely used today to cut mainstream vinyl records leading to dull, squashed and thin sounding records.

Also, he didn't state what resolution was used to cut the vinyl - but he does say that it was 'cut with the same file used for the CD', which leads to the conclusion that it was 44.1k/16bit - another huge mistake.

Second, he shows the wave forms of the vinyl and CD rips and the vinyl track displays more natural, uneven peaks - which he says is an unknown artifact and proof that vinyl dynamic range measurements are flawed. But one thing missing from that argument is how a vinyl record is cut. Even with a digital master, the signal must be fed through an analog chain. The analog output from the DAC is fed through amplifiers, processed for RIAA EQ (sometimes processed through analog compressors, expanders and further EQ'd by the cutting engineer) before being sent to the cutting head in a pure analog form. Some peaks in the analog waveform may naturally expand or contract during this analog stage and will end up being cut with a slightly different dynamic waveform profile than the digital source. Some natural compression and expansion of the signal will happen as it's being cut - that's just the nature of the format and signal chain.

Third, the equipment used to playback and record the vinyl isn't listed or talked about. Some cartridges are brighter and more dynamic than others; some are darker and fuller sounding. Not all phono preamps amplify the signal the same way and some are not as transparent as others; imprinting their own character to the signal. Not all preamps process the RIAA curve exactly the same way. Peaks are very frequency dependent and some signal/electrical interaction between the phono preamp and cartridge; and between the preamp and analog-to-digital converter will happen spontaneously and cannot be accurately measured in a quantifiable way. All of that will produce variables and differences in the recording, making each recording unique.

You can try some dynamic measurement experiments of your own - I attached the TT Dynamic Measurement plugin he uses in the video. Both Windows and Mac versions are included. There is no install, you just need to copy the files to the plugin folder of your audio editing software.

What do you think?
« Last Edit: September 17, 2014, 05:29:55 AM by Admin »
Rega P25 Zyx Omega G Zyx R100H Audio Research PH5 Denon DP-52F Denon DL-103D Burson HA-160 Sennheiser HD-650 and HD-800


November 17, 2013, 07:10:24 AM
  • lshin80
  • Premiere
  • Trade Count: (0)
  • Posts: 196 Male
    Offline
    Planet Earth Send PM
    • Share Post
That's the story of digital and CD fanatics: defending to death the presumed digital's supremacy over analog, but they don't even know what they're talking about... ::)
Pro-Ject RPM 5.1 Denon DL-110 Sony BDP-S373 Fred Nachbaur High Precision Tube Phono Preamp Nuova Elettronica FET preamp Nuova Elettronica IGBT power amp Mission 701 Clicktronic cables Norstone Loudspeaker Cable



Share via delicious Share via digg Share via facebook Share via linkedin Share via pinterest Share via reddit Share via stumble Share via tumblr Share via twitter

clip
Dynamic Range Meter plugin

Started by BSD2000 on Recording, Mixing and Mastering

0 Replies
1711 Views
Last post September 18, 2014, 04:56:47 AM
by BSD2000
xx
Cut your own vinyl?

Started by BSD2000 on Other Equipment

0 Replies
3174 Views
Last post May 26, 2012, 07:54:01 AM
by BSD2000
thumbup
Make your own vinyl record!

Started by BSD2000 on Vinyl Grooves

0 Replies
3201 Views
Last post June 09, 2012, 10:57:20 AM
by BSD2000
xx
Too cold to listen to my vinyl :(

Started by BSD2000 on Vinyl Grooves

2 Replies
4451 Views
Last post January 05, 2012, 08:00:32 AM
by BSD2000
 

web
stats